The perfect cake can really bring an event together. Cakes can not only tie in with the theme, but also remind the attendees of what they’re all gathered to celebrate in the first place. Not to mention that cakes are tasty concoctions and can bring a smile to anyone’s face.
But actually getting the perfect cake isn’t always, well, a piece of cake.
Anyone can make a cake out of a box of Betty Crocker mix, but truly divine takes require a high element of finesse. You want your cake to not only taste amazing, but also look as good as it tastes.
That’s where your local cake shops come in. Below, we’ll provide all the information you need to know about Cakes by Karen when it comes to ordering a show-stopping cake.
What’s Cakes by Karen and What Does it Offer?
About the Business
Cakes by Karen is a locally-owned, small business located in Highland, Indiana. It services Highland and all its surrounding areas.
Owned and run by Karen herself, this is an intimate family-owned business that aims to provide Indiana with the best cakes possible.
Cakes and More
As the name suggests, Cakes by Karen specializes in creating cakes for all types of events. They make custom cakes for weddings, birthdays, showers, and other special events.
In addition to making cakes, Cakes by Karen offers a wide variety of other baked goods and pastries, including muffins, cupcakes, scones, Danishes, cookies, quiche, pie, cobbler, and miniature French desserts. They also make holiday-specific desserts, such as paczki for Paczki Day.
While Cakes by Karen has a full portfolio of designs for you to browse through, they also make custom cakes. So if you have an idea in your head or an actual sketched out design, bring it in and Cakes by Karen will make it happen. It should be noted that custom cakes require an in-person consultation in order to ensure quality and clarity of the design.
Have a perfect picture in mind that you would love to see blown up onto a cake to dig into? Cakes by Karen will print out an edible copy of your picture right onto your cakes and cookies.
Cakes by Karen offers a wide variety of standard and popular flavors when it comes to their cakes and fillings. You are not limited by the options they present, however. If you have another flavor in mind they will make it happen.
Listed below are some of Cakes by Karen’s most popular flavors.
- Marble Fudge
- Pound Cake
- Red Velvet
- French Vanilla
The following flavors and types of cake are available for an extra charge:
- Flourless Chocolate
- Mocha Chocolate
- Carrot Cake
- Cheese Cake
Types of Filling:
- Bavarian Cream
- Chocolate Mousse
- Strawberry Pie
- Crème Brulee
- Raspberry Mousse
- Strawberry Mousse
- White Chocolate Mousse
- Dark Ganache Truffle
- Chocolate Hazelnut
- Butter Cream
- Chocolate Butter Cream
- Special Blend (tastes like whipped cream)
- Chocolate Special Blend
The following filling types are available for an extra charge:
- Fresh Strawberry
- Fresh Banana
- Chocolate Fondant
If you’re not quite sure what flavors to go in on, you can always partake in one of Cakes by Karen’s cake tastings. These tastings are available for a small fee and provide you the opportunity to try several flavor combinations so that you can make an informed and confident decision.
If you’re looking into a big expensive wedding cake, you should especially take advantage of this cake tasting opportunity.
Healthy Alternatives Offered at Cakes by Karen
In addition to providing a variety of flavors, Cakes by Karen also offers health-friendly cake options. Every cake can be made either sugar-free or gluten-free, and for some cakes there are vegan alternatives.
Cakes by Karen - Pricing
As with any bakery, pricing depends on exactly what you want. Different add-ons, flavor choices, and designs will cost varying amounts. Remember, you’re not only paying for the ingredients but also the labor that it takes to create your cake. Each of the cakes made by Cakes by Karen is hand-crafted to fulfill your own mental image, and that can take quite a lot of work.
The most accurate way to know how much your cake or pastry selection will cost you is to book a consultation, where you will receive a quote on your cake idea and find out what exactly qualifies as a serving.
Below we’ve listed some of the basic guidelines for cake pricing.
Standard Cake Pricing
There are several tiers that go into pricing your cake, though generally the overall price is related to price per serving. Here are some of the basics:
- Starting Price Per Serving: $2.50 for round cakes, $2.75 for other shaped cakes
- Fondant Cakes: Start at $3.50 per serving
- Fillings: An additional $0.25 per serving
- Deposit: A $50 deposit is required to reserve the date. Cakes by Karen suggests making the deposit as early as possible to ensure your cake is made as they receive many client requests each week.
It should be noted that in the case of tiered cakes, they are double-layered and include a filling or icing in between. So, tiered cakes are automatically at least $2.75 per serving.
If you need to have your cake delivered and set up, you will be responsible for paying this fee. Delivery charges vary depending on the distance of the delivery location from the shop, though the fee starts at a base of $50.
Of course, if you go to pick up the cake yourself, no delivery or handling charges are applicable.
Wedding Cake Fees and Add-Ons
When it comes to wedding cakes, there are a few extra things to keep in mind.
The top tier of wedding cakes, typically referred to as the first anniversary cake, are made free of charge so long as the cake was made to accommodate a wedding of over 100.
If you’ve ordered a tier cake and would like to top it off with a wedding topper, you can order one through Cakes by Karen for a 20% off discount.
Lastly, if like most tiered cakes your cake requires a stand, you will need to pay a safety deposit on the stand. This deposit will be refunded when the stand is returned, preferably within a week and completely cleaned.
How to Order a Cake
Cakes by Karen offers a variety of order forms on their website to make ordering your cake nice and simple. In addition to their general cake order forms, there are also season order forms that you can select from that showcases all their seasonal bests.
Of course, if you have a custom cake in mind a little more personal interaction will be required. Custom cakes require an in-person consultation. This is to help your idea be clearly communicated to the Cakes by Karen staff to ensure the cake you take home is everything you imaged it would be.
To contact the Cakes by Karen staff, you can call the business at 219-838-2310, or send an email to firstname.lastname@example.org.
Public Perception of Cakes by Karen
Customers of Cakes by Karen praise the quality of their cakes, stating that they are as beautiful as they are delicious. Karen’s frosting crafting is also highly praised, her decorating skills on par with what most can only do with fondant. Most agree that, while a little pricey, these cakes are well worth it.
There are a few others, however, who feel differently about Karen and her cakes. There have been a few complaints of cakes not matching their descriptions or sampled photos upon pickup. A few have also complained of gruff customer service.
Despite these complaints, however, no one has ever complained of the taste of these cakes. If you plan on ordering a cake from Cakes by Karen soon, we recommend simply being very clear in the design you want, leaving everyone happy.
Ordering the Cake of Your Dreams from Cakes by Karen
Cakes by Karen’s order forms and consultations are great resources to use when deciding on what type of cake you want. Before going into a consultation, however, we recommend that you already have a strong idea about what you want.
First, know what type of cake shape and the number of servings you’ll require. Your consultant will also provide you with information about what kinds of shapes work best for different party sizes.
It’s also helpful if you know roughly what flavor you want—that way you can focus in on a few key variations during any cake tasting.
Lastly, know your design. If you’re ordering a custom cake, the best way to convey what you want is to provide a visual. So, if you’re the artsy type put those drawing skills to work! Otherwise be prepared to provide design details.
The more specific you are with what you want, the better Cakes by Karen can help meet your vision.